Pleasantville Homes for Sale

Pleasantville Homes for Sale

Welcome to Pleasantville, Ohio – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Fairfield County! This charming small town is known for its welcoming community, picturesque landscapes, and a rich tapestry of history that dates back to its founding in the early 1800s. With its tree-lined streets and friendly neighbors, Pleasantville offers a serene escape from the hustle and bustle of city life, making it the perfect place to call home.

Pleasantville boasts a variety of local amenities, including quaint shops, delightful eateries, and beautiful parks, ensuring that residents have everything they need within arm’s reach. The town is also home to excellent schools, making it an ideal location for families looking to settle down and thrive. With its strong sense of community and vibrant local events, Pleasantville is a place where friendships flourish and memories are made.

For those considering a move, Pleasantville has an enticing selection of homes for sale. From charming single-family residences to modern townhouses, there’s something here for everyone. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or looking to downsize, the real estate market in Pleasantville offers a range of options to suit your needs and budget. Imagine waking up to the gentle sounds of nature, enjoying your morning coffee on a cozy porch, and spending weekends exploring the scenic beauty that surrounds you.

If you’re ready to discover your dream home in Pleasantville, Ohio, now is the perfect time to explore the wonderful opportunities this community has to offer. Come experience the charm and warmth of Pleasantville – your new home awaits!

Newest Pleasantville Homes for Sale

⋅ Tonya R Fisher

Beautiful 3 acre wooded residential lot located just outside of Pleasantville on a quiet country road. Perfect for anyone desiring a more private setting yet still near Baltimore or Lancaster for all the amenities. Property is 5 miles from Buckeye Lake!

2810 Pleasantville Road NE, Pleasantville

Listing Courtesy of : Tonya R Fisher ---- Key Realty

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Ronnie D Woodrow

Welcome home to this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offering the convenience of one-story living with an open-concept design. The spacious kitchen features granite countertops, beautiful hickory cabinetry, and flows seamlessly into the main living area. The inviting living room is highlighted by a cozy gas log fireplace, creating a warm and welcoming space. The full basement provides abundant storage and excellent potential for additional finished living space. Step outside to enjoy the fully fenced backyard with a white vinyl privacy fence, offering a great setting for outdoor activities, entertaining, or relaxing. This move-in-ready home combines quality finishes, functional living spaces, and thoughtful updates throughout.

315 Lincoln Avenue, Pleasantville

Listing Courtesy of : Ronnie D Woodrow ---- Realistar

⋅ Sherry L Looney

Welcome to 6875 Indian Run Road NE in Rushville, Ohio—1.73 scenic acres with a pond in the Fairfield Union School District, ready for your custom-built dream home. This buildable lot offers a peaceful country setting surrounded by mature trees, providing privacy, natural beauty, and plenty of space to design the home you've been envisioning. The property is ideal for those seeking rural living, a homesite with pond views, or a quiet retreat away from the city. Key items are already in place, including a well, septic system, and established driveway, significantly reducing upfront costs and simplifying the building process. With utilities completed, you can focus on construction and design rather than land preparation. **Electric Provider: South Central Power** Whether you're planning a custom home, weekend getaway, or long-term investment, this property offers an excellent combination of usable acreage, pond frontage, and school district appeal. If you've been searching for land for sale in Rushville, Ohio, buildable acreage with a pond, or property with well and septic already installed, this is a standout opportunity you won't want to miss.

6875 Indian Run Road NE, Pleasantville

Listing Courtesy of : Sherry L Looney ---- Howard HannaRealEstateServices

1 Baths ⋅ Alissa J Gilroy-Garafolo

Unlock endless potential in the heart of Pleasantville, Ohio! This former salon is perfectly positioned for its next chapter—whether you're dreaming of reviving it as a chic beauty studio or transforming the space into an entirely new concept. The property is fully equipped, move-in ready. With all existing salon equipment included in the sale, you have the option to open your doors on day one or easily reimagine the layout to suit your vision. A versatile opportunity with unlimited possibilities!

111 W Columbus Street, Pleasantville

Listing Courtesy of : Alissa J Gilroy-Garafolo ---- Vision One Real EstateAdvisors

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Justin C Schobeloch

The spacious yard offers plenty of room to roam, and the wrap-around driveway with detached two-car garage keeps your car safe from winter ice. Inside, abundant kitchen cabinet storage, and fresh updates throughout that give the home a bright, move-in-ready feel. Just 5 minutes from local groceries and the hospital, this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath, two-story home offers the perfect blend of country tranquility and everyday convenience, and there's no better season than summer to make it yours. Enjoy bloom-filled mornings and golden evenings on the inviting wrap-around porch, with sweeping views of the surrounding countryside. Lease requirements: One-year lease. $1,950 security deposit. First and last month's rent due at lease signing. No pets, no smoking.

4790 Lancaster Thornville Road NE, Pleasantville

Listing Courtesy of : Justin C Schobeloch ---- Sum Real Estate, LLC

3 Baths ⋅ Craig R Howells

This completely renovated former church offers a versatile opportunity with a spacious 3,500 sq ft sanctuary featuring beautiful hand-crafted stained glass windows and an occupancy of 200, plus an attached 3,548 sq ft banquet facility with seating for approximately 150. Just 4 miles from Buckeye Lake and 45 minutes from downtown Columbus, this property is ideal for a wide range of uses including a wedding venue, event center, music venue, performing arts space, meeting hall, daycare, family life center, or auditorium. This could be converted to a single family or multi generational home. With three restrooms and ample space throughout, this unique property is ready to serve your vision.

5831 Canal Road NE, Pleasantville

Listing Courtesy of : Craig R Howells ---- RE/MAX Town Center

Start Your Search

Malena Chhuom

I’m a results-driven agent fueled by genuine care, which means every decision I make is focused on maximizing your outcome while protecting what matters most to you. Whether you're thinking about selling, buying, or just exploring your options, I help you understand exactly where you stand—and what to do next. For homeowners, I provide a clear, data-backed picture of your home’s value and the strategies that can help you sell for more in today’s market. For buyers, I offer insight, access, and negotiation strategies that give you an edge—so you don’t miss opportunities or overpay. What sets me apart is simple: I combine smart, proven systems with a personalized approach. No pressure. No guesswork. Just honest guidance, strong execution, and real results. If you’re even considering a move, the smartest next step is understanding your options—because the right strategy changes everything.

Learn More