Highland Lakes Homes for Sale

Highland Lakes Homes for Sale

Welcome to Highland Lakes, a picturesque subdivision nestled in the charming city of Westerville, Ohio, within the vibrant Delaware County. This serene community offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and modern conveniences, making it the perfect place for families, retirees, and everyone in between.

Highland Lakes is renowned for its stunning landscapes, featuring beautiful homes that exude both character and elegance. The architecture varies from spacious single-family residences to cozy townhomes, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Each property is thoughtfully designed, boasting modern amenities and spacious layouts that cater to today’s lifestyle. Many homes in this community come with lush yards, perfect for outdoor gatherings or quiet evenings under the stars.

Residents of Highland Lakes enjoy a wealth of amenities, including scenic walking trails, well-maintained parks, and access to the shimmering Highland Lakes itself, where you can spend sunny afternoons fishing, kayaking, or simply enjoying the serene views. The community is also conveniently located near top-rated schools, shopping centers, and dining options, ensuring that everything you need is just a short drive away.

Currently, there are a variety of homes for sale in Highland Lakes, offering prospective buyers the chance to become part of this welcoming community. Whether you’re looking for a starter home or a spacious family residence, you’ll find a range of options that fit your needs and budget. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to call Highland Lakes your home—explore the listings today and discover the perfect place to create lasting memories!

Newest Highland Lakes Homes for Sale

$1,299,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Kathy L Greenwell
Simply exceptional describes this Parade of Homes custom design by Romanelli & Hughes, showcasing outstanding craftsmanship in the prestigious Highland Lakes golf community. Perfectly positioned on a spectacular wooded ravine lot with tranquil water views, a private water's edge deck, and views of the Westerville Reservoir, this remarkable property offers approximately 7,204 finished square feet, including the finished lower level. Timeless architecture, tasteful updates, and inviting outdoor living spaces combine to create an extraordinary home. The thoughtfully designed floor plan features five bedrooms, four full bathrooms, and one half bath, complemented by rich red oak hardwood flooring, soaring ceilings, expansive windows, custom millwork, and two fireplaces. The beautifully renovated kitchen showcases a massive center island, high-end appliances, walk-in pantry, and opens seamlessly to the eating area, hearth room, and dramatic two-story great room with a cozy library nook. A formal dining room, executive-style study, and first-floor laundry complete the main level. Upstairs, all five bedrooms are thoughtfully arranged, including the spacious owner's suite with a spa-inspired bath featuring designer finishes. A private ensuite bedroom, two bedrooms connected by an updated Jack-and-Jill bath, and a versatile fifth bedroom provide exceptional flexibility. The finished lower level is designed for entertaining and recreation with a spacious family room, recreation area, beautifully appointed wet bar, fitness room, full bathroom, and abundant storage. Outdoor living is equally impressive with a screened porch, pergola-covered paver patio, built-in grill, meticulous landscaping, irrigation system, and a private water's edge deck overlooking the wooded ravine. Extensive updates throughout enhance both beauty and function. Enjoy Highland Lakes amenities, parks, shopping, dining, golf opportunities, and the charm of Uptown Westerville.

5415 Stillwater Avenue, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Kathy L Greenwell ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs
$625,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Nichole Hankins
Tucked away on a quiet, no-through street, this home sits on a rare ¼+ acre lot backing to approximately 10 acres of HOA green space with mature woods, a winding creek, scenic walking trail, and no rear neighbors. Privacy like this is hard to find in the city. Inside, you'll find an exceptional floorplan with 4 bedrooms, each featuring a walk-in closet, main-floor laundry, and multiple flex rooms ideal for a home office, playroom, workout room, and hobby space. The 1,218 sq ft. finished lower level includes a bar already plumbed for a sink, generous storage closets with built-in shelving, and endless possibilities for entertaining or everyday living. The fully fenced backyard is designed for enjoying the outdoors with a patio, gazebo, mature trees, and direct views of the wooded green space beyond. Major updates include a new roof (2022), hot water heater (2024), all new kitchen appliances (2026), fresh interior and exterior paint, updated lighting throughout, and a beautifully finished lower level. Additional features include hardwood floors, a whole-house water filtration system, ADT Pulse wireless security system, surround sound wiring in the living room and newer washer/dryer remain! Conveniently located within walking distance to Meijer and the school bus stop just steps from the front of the home. Large lot, this level of privacy, and over 4,600 finished square feet are rarely found together in this location.

5529 Ainsley Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Nichole Hankins ---- Berkshire Hathaway HS Pro Rlty
$514,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Brian D Kemp
Welcome to this beautiful 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home in the desirable Highland Lakes community, located within the Westerville City School District. Offering 2,272 square feet on a .23-acre lot, this two-story home features an open floor plan, a first-floor owner's suite, and a 3-car attached garage. A dramatic two-story foyer welcomes you inside, where luxury vinyl plank flooring (2014) extends through the foyer, kitchen, dining room, great room, and 3-season room. The first-floor office features a vaulted ceiling and large window, making it an ideal workspace. The kitchen is designed for everyday living and entertaining with stainless steel appliances, a gas range, recessed lighting, bar-height seating, and seamless flow into the dining area and great room. The stunning great room showcases a vaulted ceiling, two skylights, abundant windows, ceiling fan, and a gas fireplace with a tile surround and mantel. The first-floor owner's suite offers a vaulted ceiling, ceiling fan, and private bath with tile flooring, dual vanities, soaking tub, and private water closet. A convenient first-floor laundry room adds functionality. The vaulted 3-season room provides the perfect place to relax while enjoying views of the outdoors. Upstairs are three spacious bedrooms, each with a ceiling fan, plus a full bath with tile flooring. The 1,300+/- square foot basement offers exceptional storage and endless finishing potential. Major updates include a new roof (2026), updated lighting (2025), exterior paint (2022), concrete driveway, walkway and front stoop (2022), A/C (2019), and hot water heater (2023). Combining spacious living, quality updates, and an outstanding location in one of Westerville's most sought-after neighborhoods, this home is ready for its next owner.

6752 Inverness Street, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Brian D Kemp ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs
$599,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Ranee C Brown
Welcome home to this beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence that perfectly blends timeless elegance with modern comfort. From the moment you step inside, you'll be captivated by the dramatic two-story great room, where soaring ceilings, rich hardwood flooring, a cozy fireplace, and expansive windows fill the home with an abundance of natural light, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The spacious first-floor office is ideal for working from home or creating a private library, featuring an impressive wall of custom built-in bookcases. Throughout the home, you'll appreciate the extensive updates and tasteful finishes that make it truly move-in ready. The stunning kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, offering custom cabinetry, solid surface countertops, a coordinating backsplash, and generous workspace for preparing meals and gathering with family and friends. Retreat to the luxurious first-floor owner's suite, complete with hardwood flooring, oversized windows, and beautiful neutral décor. The spa-inspired owner's bath has been thoughtfully updated with a large tiled walk-in shower, relaxing jetted soaking tub, custom cabinetry, granite countertops, custom blinds, and elegant tile flooring. Upstairs, you'll find three generously sized bedrooms, a full bath, and a spacious loft that provides the perfect setting for a second living area, media room, or play space. Step outside to enjoy your private backyard oasis, where the expansive deck, patio, and charming swing create an ideal setting for summer barbecues, morning coffee, or relaxing evenings under the stars. New roof 2026. Additional highlights include a two-car attached garage, a large basement offering endless possibilities for storage or future finished living space, and a location that makes this exceptional property one you won't want to miss. This meticulously maintained home offers the perfect combination of style, comfort, and functionality.

5225 Saint Andrews Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Ranee C Brown ---- BHHS Platinum Realty Group
$825,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Paul J George
Very hard to find rennovated 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath on cul de sac lot in Highland Lakes. All new flooring on 1st floor, white kitchen, new owners bath, (must see), tea sippin, fulll front porch, outdoor covered living area on 1/3 acre lot, funished lower level, newer roof and easy access to walking path and Highland Lakes olf Course & Country Club

5445 Forest Highlands Court, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Paul J George ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols
$1,149,000
4 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Michael A Casey
EXTRAORDINARY CUSTOM-BUILT BOB WEBB MULTI-LEVEL RESIDENCE IN THE HIGHLY SOUGHT-AFTER HIGHLAND LAKES COMMUNITY. THIS ARCHITECTURAL MASTERPIECE IS UNIQUE IN STYLE AND DESIGN A HOME THAT FEELS BOTH MODERN AND TIMELESS. THE OPEN FLOOR PLAN IS FILLED WITH NATURAL LIGHT AND SHOWCASES DESIGNER FINISHES, CUSTOM VENETIAN PLASTER WALLS, AND HIGH-END LIGHTING THROUGHOUT. THE UPDATED GOURMET KITCHEN FEATURES TWO-TONE CABINETRY, CAMBRIA COUNTERTOPS AND BACKSPLASH, NEW STAINLESS APPLIANCES WITH COPPER ACCENTS INCLUDING GAS RANGE, CUSTOM HOOD & BUILT-IN DOUBLE OVEN. THE KITCHEN AND EATING AREA OPEN TO A MULTI-LEVEL DECK OVERLOOKING THE WOODED, PARK-LIKE BACKYARD. THE DRAMATIC GREAT ROOM BOASTS SOARING CEILINGS, A WALL OF GLASS WINDOWS & A STRIKING GAS FIREPLACE. THE ELEGANT OWNER'S SUITE OFFERS CORNER WINDOWS, JETTED TUB, DOUBLE VANITY & TWO WALK-IN CLOSETS. THREE ADDITIONAL BEDROOMS INCLUDE A PRIVATE GUEST SUITE & TWO BEDROOMS WITH JACK-AND-JILL BATH. A SPACIOUS, PRIVATE OFFICE/DEN PROVIDES A QUIET RETREAT. MULTIPLE LIVING AREAS THROUGHOUT THE HOME CREATE FLEXIBILITY FOR ENTERTAINING OR RELAXATION. THE COZY FAMILY ROOM OPENS TO A PRIVATE PATIO AND FEATURES A FULLY RENOVATED MARBLE BATH. THE FINISHED LOWER LEVEL INCLUDES A LARGE RECREATION ROOM, SOUNDPROOF THEATER ROOM/5TH BEDROOM, FULL BATH, STORAGE & DIRECT ACCESS TO THE POOL AREA. OUTDOOR LIVING IS UNSURPASSED THREE LEVELS WALK OUT TO A BEAUTIFULLY LANDSCAPED WOODED LOT WITH A PRIVATE IN-GROUND POOL, GAZEBO, FIRE PIT, MULTIPLE PATIOS, AND A TRANQUIL CREEK. RECENT UPDATES INCLUDE: KITCHEN ('25), LAUNDRY ROOM ('25), HALF BATH ('25), LIGHTING ('25), GARAGE ('25), NEW ROOF ('23), EXTERIOR PAINT ('22), CUSTOM BLINDS, TANKLESS WATER HEATER, SECURITY CAMERAS & UPGRADED OUTDOOR LIGHTING. THIS REMARKABLE HOME IS A PRIVATE OASIS OF STYLE, COMFORT & FUNCTIONALITY. THIS IS A RARE OPPORTUNITY TO OWN ONE OF HIGHLAND LAKES' MOST ICONIC RESIDENCES. *** 5,126 TOTAL FINISHED SQ. FT ***

5107 Augusta Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Michael A Casey ---- RE/MAX Connection
$899,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Jeff J Scarpitti
If you thrive on natural lighting and like to entertain...then you'll love this custom build by Romanelli and Hughes. This large hillside ranch was designed for executive style living w/ over 4300 Sqft of space. UPPER LEVEL: *Home Office *Formal Dining Room *Grand Living Room (w/ hdwd floors - 12' ceilings - gas log fireplace and a wall of windows that overlooks the deck & treed reserve), *Gourmet Kitchen (that speaks for itself) - *Family Room (or sitting area) w/ gas log fireplace and ample windows) -*Large Primary Suite (w/ steam shower - jetted tub and huge closet), *1st floor laundry (just off the primary for convenience). LOWER LEVEL: *Huge entertainment area (overlooks treed reserve and patio), * 2nd Full Kitchen (w/ granite countertops, appliances and wine chiller) *Two Additional Bedrooms *2nd Full Bath *2nd Laundry area *Weather-dry Paver Patio for entertaining *Spiral Staircase from the deck above * Great Landscaping *Treed Reserve for year-round privacy. *3 miles from Alum Creek boat docks *Close to Polaris *Close to Golf Courses *Invisible Pet Fence *Minimal maintenance-- This could be the home you've been looking for!

5295 Royal County Down, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Jeff J Scarpitti ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols
$558,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Rachel R Remy
RARE OPPORTUNITY to own nearly an acre (0.82 acres) in one of Westerville's most desirable communities, Highland Lakes! Combining a hard-to-find homesite with the added security of a WHOLE-HOUSE GENERATOR, this property offers space, comfort, and peace of mind year around. Don't let the summer heat and unexpected outages disrupt your comfort. Featuring 3 bedrooms plus a versatile, finished loft ideal for a 4th bedroom, home office, or flex space, along with 2.5 baths. The highly sought-after first-floor primary suite and soaring vaulted ceilings create an open, inviting feeling throughout the main living areas. The kitchen offers stainless steel appliances, fresh paint, and an adjoining eat-in area, while the first-floor den provides the perfect work-from-home space or additional living area. Entertain with ease in the formal dining room or step outside to the beautiful paver patio overlooking the expansive backyard--perfect for a pool, playset or wildflower garden. Additional highlights include a 3-car garage, fresh interior paint, newer wood flooring, and a basement ready for your finishing touches. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, bike paths, and major highway access, all within the highly sought Westerville School District. Homes with this much land, functionality, and privacy in Highland Lakes rarely come available--don't miss this one!

6043 Congressional Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Rachel R Remy ---- JMG Ohio
$559,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Paul J George
Contingent upon home sale with escape, still show! Welcome home, from the covered front porch, to the 2 sty foyer, to the upgraded bath and to the extended family room. Welcome to 5450 St Andrews Drive in the soughtafter Highland Lakes Subdivision. This 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath 2 story in the Westerville School District has been beautifully maintained. Kitchen upgrades, Owners bath upgrades all sitting on a half acre lot. Lots of value here, paver patio, woods behind house for privacy and much more. Basement is a blank slate to finish to your imagination, located in Highland Lakes with easy access to Polaris, 71, Westerville Community Center, Uptown Westerville, Parks & Bikepaths. Country Club is easily accessible so the kids never have to cross a busy street to get to the pool. Must see, this is a good one!

5450 Saint Andrews Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Paul J George ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols
$839,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Kristina J Ledford
NEW PRICE - EXCEPTIONAL OPPORTUNITY! Why settle for builder-grade? Discover the difference of custom construction in highly sought-after Highland Lakes. Offering timeless craftsmanship, thoughtfully designed living spaces, major recent updates, and the charm of an established luxury community, this beautifully maintained 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath home is located on a quiet cul-de-sac within award-winning Olentangy Schools. Step inside to soaring ceilings and abundant natural light, highlighted by a dramatic two-story wall of windows in the great room. The versatile floor plan features a formal dining room with tray ceiling, elegant sitting room, private home office, and convenient first-floor laundry. The spacious kitchen is the heart of the home, showcasing rich wood cabinetry, granite countertops, gas cooktop, newer stainless steel appliances, pantry, breakfast bar, and an inviting eat-in area perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The luxurious primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with a double tray ceiling, spa-like bath featuring a glass shower, whirlpool tub, dual granite vanities, and a generous walk-in closet. Additional bedrooms include both Jack-and-Jill and private ensuite baths with updated finishes. The finished lower level provides exceptional flexibility with a kitchenette/bar, media area, pool table space, full bath, and fifth bedroom--ideal for guests, entertaining, hobbies, or multigenerational living. Outdoor spaces are equally inviting, featuring a low-maintenance deck with pergola, beautifully landscaped paver patio, relaxing hot tub, and plenty of green space to enjoy. Major updates include a new roof and HVAC in 2024, providing peace of mind for years to come. Enjoy all that Highland Lakes has to offer, including nearby private golf, scenic walking paths, parks, and convenient access to Polaris shopping, dining, and entertainment. MUST SEE TO APPRECIATE THE QUALITY, FLEXIBILITY, AND VALUE THIS CUSTOM HOME OFFERS!

5395 Anacala Court, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Kristina J Ledford ---- Buy Sell Ohio Realty
Start Your Search