Refine Search
Sort by
$324,900
6 Beds 6 Baths John Kohlhepp
Spacious Opportunity Near Buckeye Lake! Welcome to 11890 Broad Street in the heart of Millersport—an expansive 6-bedroom, 4.5-bath home offering incredible potential just minutes from Buckeye Lake. This large residence has had work started and is ready for a new owner to finish and customize to their vision. With its generous layout and bedroom count, this property is ideal for a vacation home, or large family retreat. Conveniently located right off the main road, you'll enjoy easy access to local restaurants, a nearby coffee shop, and all the charm Millersport has to offer—plus quick access to Buckeye Lake for boating, dining, and year-round recreation. Whether you're an investor or someone looking to create a one-of-a-kind lake-area getaway, this property presents a rare opportunity to add value in a highly desirable location.

11890 Broad Street, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : John Kohlhepp ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs

$869,000
4 Beds 3 Baths Jennifer D. Eyman
Listed below appraised value! Country living at its finest! Almost 17 Acres! This Old Style farmhouse has been immaculately updated to include kitchen in 2013, like new Appliances and added large pantry, per seller, living room has original tongue and groove hardwood flooring under carpet. Most Windows are Polaris double pane tilt in windows. Full bath off kitchen and a spacious Rec Room which could also be a 5th Bedroom. 1st Floor Primary Suite has massive walk in closet and full bath. Also includes safe room with digital lock, safe stays. Large living room has a beautiful fireplace and built in features (Fireplace can be hooked back up to gas) what a plus to have laundry on main floor as well as 2nd floor. Upstairs boasts 2 huge bedrooms, another smaller bedroom, full bath and bonus room. Also ability to access outside from the 2nd floor. The roof on the home and HVAC were installed within last 4 years. Now, lets talk outdoor SPACES!! Detached 3 car garage (20X36) with separate electric, concrete patio firepit area, playhouse with plenty of under storage, above ground pool (new liner stays, just needs installed), 2 sheds with concrete floors, large barn 34X63 includes concrete floor, electric and loft, middle barn approx 30X64 30% gravel 70% concrete with electric, 4 garage doors and side door, roof on middle barn is approx 2 years old, far barn 40X60 with electric, 3 enclosed sides, all gravel, new metal and lumber, roof also approx 2 years old (far barn currently leased to a farmer). This home has all the bells and whistles you need to create a pasture, farm acreage, and raise your family.

8485 Westfall Road SW, Amanda

Listing Courtesy of : Jennifer D. Eyman ---- Howard HannaRealEstateServices

$400,000
Vera J Flegle
PRICE REDUCED WOW! Opportunity Abounds!!! 6.24 Acres within walking distance to Buckeye Lake and The Winery! Join the LAKE LIFE! Build your Dream! Northern Local School District. Whether you are looking for that special spot to build your dream home or looking for a unique opportunity, this could be it. 333 ft of road frontage, Aprox 814 ft on the sides. See picture of the survey this is lot #4 on the survey, Parcel # 0480241440. Buyer will need to drill the well and bring in the available Electric, Gas and Sewer. Add an Additional 6.247 Acres when buying lot # 5 on the Survey Picture, Parcel # 0480241441 next door as well MLS # 225043578, For a total of nearly 12.5 Acres. See Photos! Please call before walking the properties. See A2A Remarks!

Rosewood Road NE, Thornville

Listing Courtesy of : Vera J Flegle ---- e-Merge Real Estate

$400,000
Vera J Flegle
Price Reduced!!!! Opportunity Awaits your imagination. Rare Opportunity to own 6.247 Acres within walking distance to Buckeye Lake and the Winery! Northern Local School District. Buy Today and Build your Dream Home before next boating season! 333 Ft of Frontage, Aprox. 817 Ft. on the sides. See Survey...this is lot #5 in the survey picture, parcel #0480241441. Driveway is designated. Electric, Gas, City Sewer is Available. Buyer will need to bring the utilities in. Buyer will need to Drill a Well for water source. Let your imagination run and Extend the opportunity by also purchasing the lot next door #4 in the survey picture, parcel # 0480241440, to add an additional 6.24 Acres. Can you imagine nearly 12.5 acres this close to the lake being available. Zoned A-Agricultural. Please Call and let me know if you are planning to walk it.The markers are the white poles. See A2A remarks!

13556 Rosewood Road NE, Thornville

Listing Courtesy of : Vera J Flegle ---- e-Merge Real Estate

$554,900
4 Beds 3 Baths Trudy D Tiu
Welcome to this expansive and versatile family home in the Pickerington North School District! This stunning 4-bedroom residence (with potential for 6) offers an open-concept layout perfect for modern living. The eat-in kitchen features counter seating, maple cabinets, quartz countertops, a pantry, and a butler's area leading to the dining room. The bright great room is complemented by a den/flex space and an additional office nook for convenience. Upstairs, enjoy a spacious loft ideal for relaxing or movie nights, along with a generous owner's suite boasting dual vanities, a shower, and two walk-in closets. Three additional bedrooms and a second-floor laundry with washer and dryer complete this level. The finished basement—approximately 1,000 sq ft not included in the main total—offers a second kitchen, large rec room, and a bedroom with tub, making it perfect for guests or entertaining. Outside, unwind on the large deck, gather around the firepit, and take advantage of the 2-car garage with bonus back room. Community walking paths make it great for biking or pets. Welcome home!

12353 Ebright Lane, Pickerington

Listing Courtesy of : Trudy D Tiu ---- Walker Tiu Real Estate Group

$695,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Robert J Riddle
This Buckeye Lake waterfront home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, stunning views, and inviting spaces inside and out. The main floor features a bright living room with lake views, a dining area with large sliders, and a kitchen with quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, gas range, and eat-in bar. The main-level bedroom includes a walk-in closet, while the remodeled bath feels spacious with a walk in shower, wide vanity, and open shelving. Luxury vinyl flooring runs throughout. The lower level adds 2 bedrooms, a full bath, family room with fireplace, laundry, and garage with ample storage. Step outside to enjoy a back patio perfect for entertaining, a hot tub added in 2023, and direct access to a boat dock along the walking and bike path. Conveniently located near dining and shopping in Buckeye Lake Village and Millersport, and just 30 minutes from Columbus, this home offers a true lakeside lifestyle.

3371 Shepard Avenue NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Robert J Riddle ---- New Albany Realty, LTD

$350,000
Darlene M Kuzmic
Dramatic sky views on this property are amazing! Check out the photos! Incredible building lot consisting of 10+ acres. This is a square block of land allowing for nice private placement of a house. About half the land is wooded with black walnut and other types of trees. The ground slopes upward inside the woods. Nestled in a quiet countryside setting, this 10-acre building lot offers the rare blend of privacy, open space, and natural beauty you've been dreaming of. Imagine waking up to wide-open skies, gentle breezes rolling across your land, and the soft glow of sunrise stretching over the horizon. Whether you envision a modern farmhouse, a cozy cabin retreat, or a custom estate with room for every hobby, this property delivers the space to make it happen. The land features a mix of mature trees, open meadows, and plenty of flat ground—ideal for building, gardening, recreation, or simply enjoying nature at its finest. With abundant wildlife, seasonal color, and peaceful surroundings, it's the kind of place where stress fades and inspiration grows. Create walking trails, build a dream barn, or design an outdoor oasis—the possibilities are as wide as the acreage itself. And with its convenient location just minutes from local amenities, you'll enjoy the perfect balance of seclusion and accessibility. If you're looking for a property that feels like a blank canvas wrapped in natural beauty, this 10-acre lot is ready to welcome your vision. Best to come to the property via Route 22 rather than Route 188 so you can see how quickly you can get to work.

00 Duncan Road SW, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Darlene M Kuzmic ---- Parker Realty Associates

$1,950
3 Beds 1 Baths Justin C Schobeloch
The spacious yard offers plenty of room to roam, and the wrap-around driveway with detached two-car garage keeps your car safe from winter ice. Inside, abundant kitchen cabinet storage, and fresh updates throughout that give the home a bright, move-in-ready feel. Just 5 minutes from local groceries and the hospital, this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath, two-story home offers the perfect blend of country tranquility and everyday convenience, and there's no better season than summer to make it yours. Enjoy bloom-filled mornings and golden evenings on the inviting wrap-around porch, with sweeping views of the surrounding countryside. Lease requirements: One-year lease. $1,950 security deposit. First and last month's rent due at lease signing. No pets, no smoking.

4790 Lancaster Thornville Road NE, Pleasantville

Listing Courtesy of : Justin C Schobeloch ---- Sum Real Estate, LLC

$999,995
7 Beds 5 Baths Hilary L Keys
Enjoy year-round recreation with a HUGE INDOOR POOL, complete with its own bonus kitchen and full bathroom--perfect for entertaining guests or private relaxation. Step outside to a massive outdoor patio overlooking sweeping views of the countryside, an ideal setting for gatherings, barbecues, or peaceful evenings. Experience the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and countryside charm in this expansive home set on 10 acres of rolling land. Flooded with natural light through its large, picturesque windows, this residence features brand-new flooring, updated fixtures, and an inviting, open layout ideal for modern living. The newly finished basement offers additional living and entertainment space, providing endless possibilities for a home theater, gym, or guest suite. A spacious multi-vehicle garage adds convenience and plenty of room for storage, hobbies, or a workshop. Whether you're hosting grand celebrations or savoring quiet moments surrounded by nature, this home offers the space, comfort, and serenity you've been dreaming of.

2300 Stonewall Cemetery Road SW, Lancaster

Listing Courtesy of : Hilary L Keys ---- The Columbus Agents

$30,000
Julia Robinson
Charming BUILDABLE Corner Lot at Buckeye Lake, Ohio - 0.17 Acres Discover the perfect spot to build your dream getaway or vacation home on this 0.17-acre corner lot in the heart of Buckeye Lake. Ideally located just minutes from Fairfield Beach, the boat ramp, and Buckeye Lake Winery! This lot offers convenient access to all the recreational amenities the area has to offer. Enjoy life in a golf-cart-friendly community, making trips to local attractions easy and fun. Nearby, explore the flavors of Buckeye Lake Winery or spend leisurely days on the water. Whether you're seeking a seasonal retreat or a future full-time residence, this location combines convenience, recreation, and small-town charm in one desirable package.

Circle South Road NE, Thornville

Listing Courtesy of : Julia Robinson ---- Red 1 Realty

$1,175,000
5 Beds 7 Baths Tara Bebinger
*$50k price adjustment on 6/30/26* and a brand new roof in 2026! Custom home on 3 acres in Carroll, in the Canal Winchester school district. At the heart of the home is a true gourmet kitchen designed for both function & entertaining, a centrally located first-floor office, a 2nd floor office (also makes a great den, hobby room or retreat), custom doors, soaring entryways, hardwood floors + a spacious loft. The walk-out lower level includes a private guest suite, gym, home theater & kitchenette. All bedrooms have their own bathroom including the guest bedroom in the lower level. 2nd floor laundry room. The first-floor owner's suite occupies its own private wing, complete w/a fireplace, hidden door to a generous walk-in closet, laundry, and a spa-like en suite bathroom. A dedicated elevator closet allows for a future elevator serving all three levels. Outside is an inground heated pool w/a captivating waterfall, covered patio, deck, balcony, garages for up to five vehicles, whole house generator. Built w/efficiency in mind, this home features radiant heated floors (also in one garage) & multi-zone heating & cooling for year-round comfort. Truly a must-see property, perfect for entertaining, relaxing & multi-generational living. Check out more details in the photos.

8322 Benson Road, Carroll

Listing Courtesy of : Tara Bebinger ---- Keller Williams Consultants

$324,900
3 Beds 1 Baths Dave Angus
Build-Ready Acreage with Utilities in Place | Garage & Pole Barn | 5 Miles to I-70. Unlock the potential of this versatile acreage property offering a rare combination of flat, usable land, existing utilities, and valuable outbuildings--ideal for building your dream home or creating a private country retreat. The property features a mix of open cleared ground and mature trees, providing both usability and natural privacy. With a newer well and septic system already in place, you can significantly reduce the cost and timeline of new construction. A detached garage and pole barn add immediate value, offering space for storage, equipment, hobbies, or future use--perfect for those needing room to work or expand. While the existing home requires significant renovation, the real opportunity lies in the land and infrastructure. Whether you choose to renovate, replace, or build new, this property offers the flexibility to bring your vision to life. Conveniently located just 5 miles from I-70, this property offers the perfect balance of rural privacy and easy access for commuting to Lancaster, Columbus, and surrounding areas. Highlights: 1. Flat, usable acreage with a mix of cleared land and trees 2. Newer well and septic system already in place 3. Ideal for new construction or custom build 4. Detached garage + pole barn for storage or workspace 5. Private setting with room to expand 6. Existing home offers renovation or tear-down potential 7. Only 5 miles to I-70 for easy commuting 8. Reduced development costs with utilities already established.

9915 Lancaster Newark Road NE, Baltimore

Listing Courtesy of : Dave Angus ---- Carol Goff & Assoc.

$574,900
3 Baths Craig R Howells
This completely renovated former church offers a versatile opportunity with a spacious 3,500 sq ft sanctuary featuring beautiful hand-crafted stained glass windows and an occupancy of 200, plus an attached 3,548 sq ft banquet facility with seating for approximately 150. Just 4 miles from Buckeye Lake and 45 minutes from downtown Columbus, this property is ideal for a wide range of uses including a wedding venue, event center, music venue, performing arts space, meeting hall, daycare, family life center, or auditorium. This could be converted to a single family or multi generational home. With three restrooms and ample space throughout, this unique property is ready to serve your vision.

5831 Canal Road NE, Pleasantville

Listing Courtesy of : Craig R Howells ---- RE/MAX Town Center

$224,000
2 Beds 2 Baths J. Andrew Bruck
Beautifully updated Buckeye Lake area bungalow located on a quiet street with 2 lots and just a short walk to downtown Millersport. The home features: 2 bedrooms with a newly added Jack and Jill 1/2 bath; a living room with refinished original hardwood floors; updated kitchen with a breakfast nook; a first-floor laundry; newer HVAC; attic insulation and a fully renovated bath. The front screen porch is perfect for entertaining and enjoying peaceful evenings. Outside you'll find a patio and entrance to a dry usable basement. The 2nd lot gives plenty of room to store a boat, trailer or add a future garage. Total lot size is 64x100. Some furnishings may be negotiable. Freezer to convey with the property Agent is related to seller

12291 Ohio Avenue, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : J. Andrew Bruck ---- Oreste Realty, LLC

$574,900
Craig R Howells
This completely renovated former church offers a versatile opportunity with a spacious 3,500 sq ft sanctuary featuring beautiful hand-crafted stained glass windows and an occupancy of 200, plus an attached 3,548 sq ft banquet facility with seating for approximately 150. Just 4 miles from Buckeye Lake and 45 minutes from downtown Columbus, this property is ideal for a wide range of uses including a wedding venue, event center, music venue, performing arts space, meeting hall, daycare, family life center, or auditorium. This could be converted to a single family or multi generational home. With three restrooms and ample space throughout, this unique property is ready to serve your vision.

5831 Canal Road NE, Pleasantville

Listing Courtesy of : Craig R Howells ---- RE/MAX Town Center